
Anna Maria is one of Florida's best-kept secrets. The seven-mile-long island is not only known for its spectacular beaches with soft, white sand, but for its many waterfront restaurants and culinary jewels too. Whether you are looking for some hearty, mouth-watering seafood or a more upscale bistro where you can have an intimate candle-lit dinner, you'll definitely find your ideal restaurant among our list of top 10 favorite restaurants. Our real estate agents share where to dine on Anna Maria Island.
- The Waterfront Restaurant - 111 S. Bay Blvd., Anna Maria
The Waterfront Restaurant is your spot for the best fish tacos and steaks on the island. Featuring a seasonally updated menu using local produce, The Waterfront is sure to please with a dazzling variety of meals with natural flavors. If you're looking for Anna Maria homes for sale, be sure to check out this island favorite.
- Blue Marlin - 121 Bridge St., Bradenton Beach
With a focus on fresh ingredients, the owners of the Blue Marlin serve only local-caught fish, hand-selected from the AP Bell Fish Co. Choose from Thai, Pecan, or Fulford preparation of your entree. gives you a choice on how you want your food prepared. The Blue Marlin restaurant is a must if you're looking for Bradenton Beach homes for sale.
- Sandbar Restaurant - 100 Spring Ave., Anna Maria
This iconic landmark features a unique location on the white sand beach of Anna Maria Island. The Sandbar Restaurant includes a huge outdoor patio for true beachfront dining. Visitors can sink their toes into the soft sand while they sip their cocktails and enjoy a meal of fresh seafood. Be sure to try their famous margaritas, coconut shrimp, and grouper sandwiches.
- Eat Here - 5315 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach
Eat Here offers mouth-watering seafood and a laid-back atmosphere. The skilled chefs here combine locally sourced ingredients with global cuisine ingredients to offer delectable meals to its customers. Looking to relocate in the area? Check out some of the best Holmes Beach homes for sale after you've had your fill at Eat Here.
- Beach Bistro - 6600 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach
Beach Bistro is the big sister of Eat Here, offering a romantic and luxurious dining room. If you can afford a special celebratory dinner, you'll want to try this restaurant. It has some of the most talented chefs in the region and features modern and innovative takes on traditional seafood and mouth-watering ribs. Remember, though – you'll need to make a reservation when visiting this restaurant.
- Beach House Restaurant - 200 Gulf Drive N., Bradenton Beach
Beach House Restaurant offers one of the best upscale dining experiences on Anna Maria Island. Located on a scenic beach with impressive water views, the restaurant has become the island's most popular event venues and a favorite for many travelers because of the incredible seafood. Its menu is diverse and includes a wide variety of foods, from raw oysters to house-smoked fish dip to vegetable risotto.
- Hurricane Hanks - 5346 Gulf Drive, Holmes Beach
With a full-service bar and fantastic margaritas, Hurricane Hanks is a more casual spot for people looking to enjoy scrumptious seafood and some cocktails. Its menu offers a little of everything, including yummy daily specials for both lunch and dinner.
- Dry Dock Waterfront Grill - 412 Gulf Of Mexico Drive, Longboat Key
Whether you are looking to enjoy a gluten-free meal or some mouth-watering grouper sandwiches with your family, Dry Dock Waterfront Grill is definitely a great restaurant to try. Whether you choose to dine in their second-story dining area or the dockside patio, you'll enjoy a panoramic view of Sarasota Bay. Be sure to check out some Longboat Key homes for sale after your meal.
- Eliza Ann's Coastal Kitchen - 5325 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach
Situated just a few steps from the edge of the water, Eliza Ann's Coastal Kitchen is your ideal restaurant if you're looking to enjoy the best of local cuisine. As the locals will tell you, they have some of the best-grilled oysters, fresh local catches, and vegetable meals.
There you have it! If you've fallen in love with Anna Maria Island, our agents are ready to help you find the home of your dreams. Contact Wagner Realty today.